[CMI-CM] How Radical?

[benjamin w harp]

"Buy Nothing Day" and the Marketplace Mall ride are both good ideas.  But,
the timing could not be worse.  

The weekend right after Thanksgiving is the biggest holiday shopping time
of the year.  Which means most of the folks we encounter will be doing
Christmas shopping.  Harrassing christmas shoppers will make us look
really bad.  I know we would try to make it fun and friendly, but many
people would see it as harrassment.

The timing of "Buy Nothing Day" is unfortunate.  Even if millions of
people refuse to buy anything, it will still be a busier than average
buisiness day.  

Thanksgiving and Christmas both celebrate consumerism.  If we attack
consumerism now, we will be seen as anti-thanksgiving, anti-christmas.
This is one of the worst times we could choose to attack consumerism.

Ben



On Fri, 17 Nov 2000, Paul Riismandel wrote:

> I think it would be a great idea to get more radical, though honestly I 
> think the group needs to be built up more.  The Buy Nothing Day is an 
> especially good idea, though I am not confident that a large enough group 
> can be gathered for then.  (For example, I'll be out of town, as I'm sure 
> many other folks will be--can we count on enough new people?).
> 
> I think the biggest thing that's holding CM back is that not enough people 
> are taking to heart the leader-less nature.  There's just been a few of us 
> doing most of the organizing, including making routes and 
> publicizing.  Unfortunately these same few can only do so much--we're 
> mostly overcommitted.
> 
> If CM is going to work here, more folks have to take it upon themselves to 
> publicize it, get more people out and contribute ideas for routes and 
> action.  I know it's tough to think this way in a culture where we're 
> always taught to obey the person who's in charge, but there's nobody in 
> charge here (even though some people have stepped up in the absence of any 
> other direction).  You don't need permission to make a flyer or some other 
> publicity--just do it!
> 
> The whole point of CM is that it's an "organized coincidence," but if the 
> same folks are always doing the organizing, then the "coincidental" part 
> fades away, and when those core people fade away, so does the Mass.
> 
> If everyone took a little time to make just a few flyers and posted them, 
> sent e-mails, got a few more friends to come, contacted someone in the 
> press, made a website... etc., then nobody would have to put in too much 
> effort and the Mass wouldn't live or die based on the efforts of just a few.
> 
> So, in sum, I think the Buy Nothing Day idea is great, but I doubt that 
> there is Mass big enough to make this a useful and safe venture for those 
> who choose to participate.  I think that some more building of the group 
> (our peak number were during Summer Break, for cryin' out loud!) is 
> necessary before more radical actions can be undertaken.
> 
> And please, everyone chime in with your thoughts and disagreements with my 
> assessment.  I don't want to argue, I'd love to be disputed--in fact, 
> silence would sadly only prove my point.
> 
> --Paul
> 
> 
> At 06:02 AM 11/17/00 -0600, Zachary C.Miller wrote:
> >Hey folks don't forget Critical Mass is on the Friday after
> >Thanksgiving. The biggest shopping day of the year. It is also Buy
> >Nothing Day. Lets see if we can do something to make this mass
> >MASSIVE. Lets start brain storming now what we can do to really get
> >people out to this thing. Lets try to aim for getting more townies out
> >since a lot of students will be away for the holiday.
> >
> >I had one crazy idea. I don't know how radical and crazy people want
> >to be but I thought it might be fun and in the spirit of Critical Mass
> >to take a ride _through_ market place mall. We could do it in a fairly
> >orderly manner and if we plan it out ahead of time we can try to be in
> >and out before mall security knew what hit them. If we do this we
> >would have to be really tight and prepared and we should have a very
> >serious message ready, lots of signs, flyers to hand out. Lots of
> >boomboxes with fun tunes to keep spirits high and attract attention.
> >
> >If there is a significant number of people who want to do this but
> >some other people are uncomfortable with actually going in the mall we
> >could always ride to the mall and then split up, one group goes
> >through and the other goes around and meets us on the other side.
> >
> >Comments? Discussion? Alternative Ideas?
> >
> >My main goal is to start making Critical Mass rides more
> >interesting. Rather than just ride around and yelling we should have a
> >special theme/event whenever possible and try to tie into things.
> >
> >--
> >Zachary C. Miller - @= - http://wolfgang.groogroo.com/
> >IMSA 1995 - UIUC 2000 - Just Another Leftist Muppet
> >  Social Justice, Community, Nonviolence, Decentralization, Feminism,
> >  Sustainability, Responsibility, Diversity, Democracy, Ecology
> >Take it easy...but take it. - http://www.greens.org
> >
> >
> >
> >_______________________________________________
> >Critical-mass mailing list
> >Critical-mass at lists.groogroo.com
> >http://lists.groogroo.com/cgi-bin/listinfo/critical-mass
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Critical-mass mailing list
> Critical-mass at lists.groogroo.com
> http://lists.groogroo.com/cgi-bin/listinfo/critical-mass
>