[Peace-discuss] UN finds no long range Iraqi Missles

[patton paul]

U.N. Finds No Long-Range Iraqi Missiles
1 hour, 8 minutes ago

By CHARLES J. HANLEY, AP Special Correspondent

The U.N. inspectors swarming over Iraq's missile industry found an
infraction last week: The short-range Al Samoud 2 sometimes flies a few
miles farther than allowed. But the experts have reported no sign of any
longer-range missiles that could strike Israel or neighboring oil nations
as Washington fears.

In fact, after three months' intensive work, the U.N. teams are looking
ahead to ending their current investigative phase, and moving on to
long-term monitoring via electronic "eyes and ears." Such a system could
rein in missile development for years, experts say.

Chief U.N. arms inspector Hans Blix gave Iraq until Saturday to begin
destroying the Al Samouds, and Baghdad was reported Thursday to have
agreed in principle to go ahead with their elimination  via explosives,
crushing, cutting or other means.

Blix called it an important test of Iraq's cooperation with U.N.
disarmament efforts. The Iraqis must also eliminate the design data and
equipment to build the weapons  a damaging blow to their young missile
industry.

Under the U.N. arms control regime that followed the 1991 Gulf War (news -
web sites), Iraq was forbidden to have missiles that could travel beyond a
150-kilometer range  93 miles. That's considered the outer limit of
short-range or "battlefield" missiles.

Blix reported the newly developed Al Samoud 2 exceeded that limit on 13
test flights, by no more than 20 miles. On 27 of 40 flights, the missile
tested short of the permitted threshold, Blix told U.N. diplomats behind
closed doors.

The Al Samouds' technical violation "isn't particularly worrisome ...
isn't dramatic," said Victor Mizin, a former missile inspector in Iraq.

He said he saw Blix's ban, announced last week, "more as a political move"
to assert U.N. control in Baghdad at a time when the Bush administration,
threatening war against Iraq, contends U.N. inspections are ineffective.

The Iraqis protested the ban, contending the flights would come up shorter
when missiles were fully loaded with warheads and guidance systems.

"They have a point," said Aaron Karp, a missile proliferation expert at
Virginia's Old Dominion University. "I'm sure there's a heavy version and
a light version."

"All missile experts will tell you it's very difficult to precisely find
the range," said Mizin, a Russian former arms negotiations adviser who
served three tours as an Iraq inspector. "It depends on how it's launched,
the flight profile. There are all kinds of trade-offs between payload and
actual range."

The slender white Al Samoud is not part of some hidden Iraqi arms program.
It was under U.N. scrutiny from its first rollout, in 1997, when
inspectors probed and tested it with gauges and scales to check its
capabilities.

When the U.N. teams returned last November after a four-year absence, they
again descended on the Al Samoud factories, copied design files, observed
engine tests and held long meetings, day after day, with Al Samoud
production team leaders behind the 9-foot-high walls of their Karama
Company compound in north Baghdad.

It was the Iraqis, however, not the inspectors, who declared the technical
violations of the range limit  violations the U.N. experts then confirmed
via computer modeling.

At the same time, inspectors were making dozens of other unannounced
visits to design, production and test sites to check for more serious
violations. Reports by the U.S. and British governments, based on
satellite photos showing expansion of missile industry sites, said the
Iraqis might be developing missiles with ranges over 600 miles.

But after the on-the-ground inspectors looked under the roofs in those
photos, they reported no violations.

Similarly, after three months of unfettered U.N. access in Iraq, no signs
have been reported of "up to a few dozen" longer-range Scud missiles the
U.S. and British intelligence reports speculated were illegally hidden by
the Baghdad regime. Those reports contended, without offering evidence,
that the Iraqis saved some of the imported, Soviet-made missiles from U.N.
destruction in the 1990s.



Both Mizin and Karp believe inspectors should focus suspicions on the
possibility Iraq will upgrade missile guidance by incorporating technology
that uses Global Positioning System (news - web sites) satellites. This
could make primitive "cruise missiles"  airplanes converted to bomb-laden
unmanned drones  much more accurate.

Along those lines, in February alone the U.N. inspectors have paid at
least a half-dozen surprise visits to installations making
guidance-and-control systems. They're also inspecting sites where unmanned
aircraft are developed.

In February, the missile inspectors began unspecified preparatory work for
the long-term monitoring system envisioned under U.N. resolutions. That
system will include around-the-clock cameras and other monitoring devices
inside and outside plants, along with regular oversight visits to
missile-industry sites.

Missiles, with their test facilities, test flights and large pieces of
gear, are especially susceptible to monitoring, the experts agreed. "There
are things you ultimately can't hide," Karp said.

In any U.S. war, the Al Samoud missiles might threaten advancing American
forces, although they might also be knocked out in pre-emptive U.S.
airstrikes.

Now Iraq faces the painful order to destroy its 50 or more Al Samouds,
along with stocks of engines, liquid fuel, production and launch
equipment, design and production software and documents.

In the 1970s and 1980s, Iraq was believed to have wasted $10 billion of
its oil money in a failed bid to build missiles. It finally succeeded with
the Al Samoud in the 1990s, and went on to build a second line of
short-range missile, the solid-fuel al-Fatah (news - web sites). Losing
the Al Samoud program now would be a major setback to its
military-industrial complex.

___

EDITOR'S NOTE: AP Special Correspondent Charles J. Hanley has been in Iraq
covering the U.N. weapons inspections.