[Peace-discuss] Fw: Re:Re: Fwd:Berg video exposed as a fraud

[jencart at mailstation.com]

A friend sent this.  Long, raises questions...

-----Forwarded Message-----
Subject: Re:Re: Fwd:Berg video exposed as a fraud

At 10:36 AM 5/26/2004 -0400, you wrote:

>NYT has apologised for consistently featuring lies on the front page and 
>burying the truth twds the back of the paper.  Better late than never?  Do 
>we forgive them?  Do we trust that things will be different from now on??
>
>Jenifer

Here is the text from an article from today's NYT. In this article it is 
stated as "fact" that Berg was detained by the Iraqis. This is denied by 
the Iraqis. There is very strong evidence that he was detained by the US. 
The article also states that Berg was released after his parents filed 
suit. It doesn't say that his parents filed suit with the US Military and 
they believed that the US had him, not the Iraqis.

So much for the NYT "apology".

Note, too, that in the same sentence it links the detention with "insurgent 
violence singling out foreign contractors" - but it does not mention that 
the US guy running the show in Iraq (Bremer?) issued directives that 
foreign contractors were above Iraqi law - ie, they could disregard Iraqi 
law and the Iraqis could do nothing about it and the the US would not.



May 26, 2004




Tracing a Civilian's Odd Path to His Gruesome Fate in Iraq

By JAMES DAO

51a8155.jpghis article was reported by James Dao, Richard Lezin Jones, 
Christine Hauser and Eric Lichtblau and was written by Mr. Dao.

Nicholas E. Berg had a distinctive strategy for soliciting work for his 
communications tower company: conduct free spot inspections, then offer to 
fix any problems. Where others went sightseeing, he went climbing and 
inspecting. Where others wrote postcards, he inventoried towers, from Texas 
to Africa.

By late last year, Mr. Berg, 26, had turned his sights on Iraq. An 
adventurous entrepreneur and religious Jew, Mr. Berg had a passionate 
belief in capitalism's power to transform poor nations. He really believed, 
friends and relatives said, that he could help rebuild that war-shattered 
country one radio tower at a time.

It was a vision that almost immediately aroused suspicions. In January, the 
Iraqi police, thinking Mr. Berg might be an Iranian spy, briefly detained 
him while he was touring towers near the south-central city of Diwaniya.

"Isn't this starting to read like a mystery novel," he wrote to his friends 
and family following his Diwaniya adventure.

Two months later, Mr. Berg would not be so lucky. Late on the evening of 
March 24, the Iraqi police in Mosul, apparently thinking Mr. Berg a spy, a 
smuggler or a terrorist, detained him while he was traveling to visit two 
business contacts.

This time, he remained in an Iraqi jail for 13 days while the Federal 
Bureau of Investigation checked and rechecked his story. When he was 
released on April 6 one day after his family filed suit demanding his 
release Iraq was being swept by insurgent violence singling out foreign 
contractors.

On April 10, the day Mr. Berg planned to return home, he disappeared. On 
May 8, American troops found his body near a highway overpass in Baghdad. 
The Central Intelligence Agency has said Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, a Jordanian 
militant with ties to Al Qaeda, is probably the man seen beheading Mr. Berg 
in a ghastly videotape.

Mr. Berg's detention in Mosul has raised sharp questions about whether 
American officials did enough to get him released as quickly as they could 
have. Mr. Berg's family contends he had planned to leave Iraq on March 30, 
which might have enabled him to avoid the anti-Western kidnappings and 
killings of April.

"Were it not for Nick's detention, I would have had him in my arms again," 
Mr. Berg's father, Michael, wrote in a letter in support of a demonstration 
by an antiwar group last week. In the letter, Mr. Berg blamed the Bush 
administration more than terrorists for his son's death.

But the many unexplained details of Mr. Berg's final days, combined with 
the uncommon details of his unconventional life, have also prompted furious 
speculation on the Internet and talk radio about Mr. Berg himself. Some 
have argued that he was a spy for Israel or the C.I.A., or that the video 
of his murder was staged by pro-American forces to arouse anger toward 
Iraqi insurgents. Some have asserted that he had ties to the very Qaeda 
militants who are believed to be responsible for his death.

He was, after all, traveling alone, without a translator or a bodyguard, in 
a lawless land whose language he barely understood. He carried books about 
Iran and kept a detailed inventory of Iraqi communications towers. He was 
shown in the beheading video wearing orange clothing, which, to some, 
looked like the jumpsuits worn by prisoners held by the American military.

Adding to the mystery, both the Iraqi police and the American military deny 
responsibility for Mr. Berg's detention. The Iraqi police contend they 
promptly turned Mr. Berg over to the American military, an assertion Mr. 
Berg later confirmed in e-mail home. But American officials assert he 
remained in the custody of Iraqi police for the entire 13 days.

American law enforcement and intelligence officials have strenuously 
rejected the conspiracy theories. Mr. Berg was detained because his 
activities seemed suspicious, and once those suspicions were dispelled, he 
was released, they said. They are convinced, they said, that Mr. Berg was 
just a freelancing businessman with a high tolerance for risk, whose 
naïveté and idealism blinded him to Iraq's treacherous corners.

"He was in the wrong place at the wrong time," an F.B.I. official said.

To Mr. Berg's friends and family, there was nothing odd or mysterious about 
his wanderings in Iraq. He was just being Nick: a bright, fearless, 
iconoclastic man who saw himself as a modern-day Prometheus, bringing 
progress to a downtrodden nation. And like Prometheus, his friends say, he 
was punished for his good deeds.

"I'm sure that throughout the entire ordeal, he felt no fear," a close 
friend, Luke Lorenz, said of Mr. Berg's final hours. "I doubt that he 
thought they would hurt him. He really believed in the goodness of people. 
That if they took the time, they'd like him."

"When I see him sitting there in the video, it doesn't seem any different 
than when I'd see him anywhere else," Mr. Lorenz, 28, said. "Taking it all in."

Mr. Berg, the youngest of three children, grew up in a comfortable 
community of split-level houses in West Whiteland Township, Pa., a suburb 
of Philadelphia.

By high school, he was a prolific inventor. Among his favorite gadgets was 
the "truth detector," a palm-size box wrapped in duct tape that flashed 
lights when its wires were attached to a finger.

One summer, the police detained Mr. Berg and some friends, suspecting they 
had used the device to open garage doors. Mr. Berg became so animated in 
explaining his invention that a police officer put him in handcuffs until a 
detective checked out his story, friends recalled.

When he was a teenager, a teacher gave him an old bike. He proceeded to 
strip away all but the 10th gear the hardest. He christened the bike 
Ulysses and crisscrossed the steep hills of Pennsylvania and New York, 
riding as far as Georgia one summer.

"He didn't do much to fix it," Mr. Lorenz said, "as if he wanted to make 
things harder for himself."

He attended Cornell University, distinguishing himself in engineering 
courses, a faculty adviser said. But his defining semester came in a small 
Ugandan village, where he spent the spring of 1998 in an exchange program. 
There he was exposed to poverty he had never imagined, friends said. He 
turned his inventiveness to good use, fashioning a brick-making machine to 
help villagers stabilize mud huts. In letters, he described schemes to help 
the Ugandans market mushrooms and make bricks from indigenous materials.

"He was shaken by his experience," a friend, James Wakefield, 52, said. "He 
had nothing but a pair of pants, a shirt and boots when he came home. He 
gave away his clothing."

Friends say Mr. Berg's Africa experience made him impatient with 
traditional academics. He left Cornell at the end of 1998, despite being on 
the dean's list and having only one year left, school officials said.

He spent the next two years searching for ways to transform his Africa 
ideas into a practical plan, studying at Drexel University and the 
University of Pennsylvania before transferring to the University of 
Oklahoma in Norman in the fall of 1999.

In Oklahoma's construction science program, he began testing designs for 
paper bricks that snapped together like Lego blocks, believing they could 
be manufactured inexpensively in undeveloped countries.

"He didn't seem willing to sit around and wait to be spoon-fed stuff," said 
William W. McManus, an associate professor of construction science at 
Oklahoma. "He was always pushing on his own."

In Oklahoma, Mr. Berg's e-mail password was obtained by an associate of 
Zacarias Moussaoui. Mr. Moussaoui, who is awaiting trial on charges of 
assisting the Sept. 11 plot, attended flight school in Norman in 2001, but 
it is not clear that he ever met Mr. Berg.

F.B.I. agents interviewed Mr. Berg in 2002 and came away convinced that he 
had either shared the password with someone who passed it on to Mr. 
Moussaoui or that the password had been stolen from him. The F.B.I. cleared 
Mr. Berg of having links to terrorist groups, officials said.

In Oklahoma, Mr. Berg also began learning about communications towers. As a 
youth he had loved climbing; he built a three-story treehouse in his 
backyard and in college was an avid rock climber. In 2000, he quit his 
studies in Norman and for more than a year wandered across Oklahoma and 
Texas working as a freelance contractor replacing lights, painting girders 
and fixing cables hundreds of feet above the ground.

By 2002, he had returned to the Philadelphia area and formed his own tower 
company, Prometheus Methods Tower Service, using as a motto, "Man is more 
than fire tamed." Through cold calls and free spot inspections, he had 
built a client list of 50 companies by 2003.

Jay Shur, of WCHE-AM in West Chester, Pa., received one of those cold calls 
and was surprised by Mr. Berg's youth when they met. "I thought he would 
have been a little bit older," Mr. Shur said. "He knew exactly what to do, 
when to take charge."

As his business grew, Mr. Berg began plotting ways to resume his work in 
developing nations. With the help of the American Jewish World Service, he 
visited Kenya for two weeks in March 2003, working on water projects and 
pledging to return in the summer of 2004.

But it was Iraq that loomed large in Mr. Berg's imagination. While 
traveling to Kenya, he wrote e-mail fondly describing some Texans "rushing 
toward the action" in Baghdad as the American-led invasion was getting 
under way, even as other Westerners were fleeing with "sweaty hands."

Back in Pennsylvania, Mr. Berg defended the invasion, arguing that it had 
ousted a brutal dictator. And he argued that Americans had a moral 
obligation to help rebuild the shattered country. In part, friends said, he 
saw a business opportunity. In December 2003 he attended a convention in 
Virginia on rebuilding Iraq. Government officials and private contractors 
at the convention encouraged businesses to join in the reconstruction.

But his feelings were heavily influenced by his Judaism and his moral 
beliefs, friends said. Mr. Berg was raised in a secular Jewish household 
but became increasingly religious after college, studying the Torah and 
learning to keep kosher. He seemed particularly attracted to the Hebrew 
concept of tikkun olam healing the world through social action.

"He went to Iraq to see if he could combine his professional skill with his 
desire to heal the world," said Ruth W. Messinger, the former Manhattan 
borough president who leads the American Jewish World Service.

His views differed sharply from those of many of his friends and his 
father, a retired high school teacher who actively opposed the war. But 
though his parents and friends warned him of the dangers of Iraq, they were 
not surprised when he decided to go.

"Nick was real good at recognizing physical danger; it's part of the job," 
Scott Hollinger, the foreman for Prometheus Methods, said. "He didn't do 
too well at recognizing human danger because he never thought anybody was 
going to hurt him."

In late December, he flew to Israel and crossed by land into Iraq via 
Jordan. For the next month, Mr. Berg operated in Iraq much the same as he 
did in the United States: touring the countryside, usually by taxi, 
inspecting towers and building a database, he told friends.

One trip took him to Abu Ghraib, the neighborhood outside Baghdad that is 
now famous for its prison complex. Another took him north to Mosul. He also 
made contact with an Iraqi businessman, Aziz al-Taee, who had lived in 
Philadelphia for 20 years before returning to Baghdad after the fall of 
Saddam Hussein.

Mr. Taee, who owned electronic equipment stores in Philadelphia, pleaded 
guilty in 1994 to selling plastic vials that were used by crack dealers. 
Mr. Berg told friends that he found Mr. Taee "very competent" and that the 
two planned to create a company called Babylon Towers.

"The fact alone that he and I are just now sitting in a free and open 
Internet shop is unbelievable to most Iraqis," Mr. Berg wrote to friends in 
January.

Mr. Berg went home in February but returned to Iraq in March, expressing 
confidence about getting work from the Harris Corporation, a company based 
in Florida that had a $96 million contract to rebuild Iraq's media 
industry. Jan Bosman, the regional program manager in the north for the 
Iraqi Media Network, said Mr. Berg went to his office in Mosul in late 
March looking for work. Mr. Bosman said Mr. Berg seemed casual about the 
security situation in the country, traveling by taxi and staying in local 
hotels.

On March 24, while traveling to meet some business contacts, Mr. Berg was 
stopped at an Iraqi checkpoint near Mosul. "We were afraid for his life," 
the police chief, Mohammad Barhawi, said in an interview. "And we had 
suspicions about him. So we turned him over to the coalition forces."

Mr. Barhawi said the Iraqi police took Mr. Berg to its headquarters and 
handed him over immediately to coalition forces in an operations room 
inside the same compound, where the American military police have a liaison 
office.

He asserted that Mr. Berg was in Iraqi hands for "minutes," but American 
officials contend that Mr. Berg remained in Iraqi police custody the entire 
time he was detained.

During his detention, Mr. Berg was interviewed three times by F.B.I. agents 
who asked whether he had ever built a pipe bomb, what he was doing in Iraq, 
why he had gone to Iran, Mr. Berg told friends and his family later. He had 
never been to Iran but was carrying a book about Iran and some Farsi 
language materials, he wrote.

Mr. Berg also told friends that while he was in jail, other prisoners 
chanted "Isralein," apparently believing he was an Israeli. (He had an 
Israeli stamp in his passport.) American soldiers ordered the Iraqi guards 
to put him in a separate cell near political and war criminals from India, 
Pakistan, Afghanistan and Iran, Mr. Berg wrote.

By then, Mr. Berg's parents, who had expected their son to return home on 
March 30, had become frantic. They contacted the State Department and were 
interviewed by the F.B.I., which corroborated Mr. Berg's statements in 
Iraq. The F.B.I. then recommended that Mr. Berg be released, F.B.I. 
officials said.

But when Mr. Berg was not immediately released, his parents filed a lawsuit 
on April 5, asserting that the American military was violating their son's 
civil rights. He was released the next day, April 6.

Mr. Berg's family contends that the swift release of Mr. Berg after the 
filing of the lawsuit proved that the American military had controlled 
their son's detention all along.

Upon his release, Mr. Berg sent e-mail saying he planned to catch a flight 
home from Jordan on April 10. He disappeared soon after that.

The next time Mr. Berg was seen publicly was on the grisly video showing 
his beheading. On the video, a masked man refers to the humiliation of 
Muslim prisoners at Abu Ghraib, prompting some to speculate that Mr. Berg 
was dressed in orange to simulate Muslim prisoners held there and at 
Guantánamo Bay.

Though Mr. Berg's Moussaoui connection has fueled speculation that F.B.I. 
agents would not allow him to be released out of concern that he had links 
to terrorists, officials in Washington deny that.

"What was this guy doing there in the first place?" an F.B.I. official 
said. "It's not as if Iraq suddenly turned hostile."

Such comments anger Mr. Berg's friends, who say he went to Iraq in part 
because he thought American officials and corporate leaders wanted American 
entrepreneurs to help rebuild the country.

"They can keep looking for a conspiracy, but they won't find anything at 
all," said Douglas Strickland, 25, a close friend.

Mr. Strickland and other friends have created a Web site devoted to Mr. 
Berg's memory, www.nickberg.org, and are raising money for a memorial fund 
to support the kind of work he did overseas.

Last week, Mr. Strickland and a friend cleaned out Mr. Berg's one-bedroom 
apartment in West Chester, Pa. They found electronic devices, handwritten 
notebooks, prototype bricks, maps of the Middle East and Africa, and an 
American flag made of red and white duct tape on blue cloth. On the wall 
was a Calvin and Hobbes cartoon that struck Mr. Strickland as typically Nick.

In it, Calvin and his stuffed tiger, Hobbes, are surveying a field of 
virgin snow. "It's like having a big white sheet of paper to draw on!" 
Hobbes says. "It's a magical world, Hobbes ol' buddy," Calvin replies. 
"Let's go exploring."

Copyright 2004 <http://www.nytco.com/>The New York Times Company | 
<http://www.nytimes.com/>Home | 
<http://www.nytimes.com/ref/membercenter/help/privacy.html>Privacy Policy | 
<http://query.nytimes.com/search/advanced/>Search | 
<http://www.nytimes.com/corrections.html>Corrections | 
<http://www.nytimes.com/membercenter/sitehelp.html>Help | Back to Top


Michael
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: 51a8155.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 1411 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.cu.groogroo.com/cgi-bin/private/peace-discuss/attachments/20040527/f76a8349/51a8155.jpg