[Peace-discuss] Why We Fight

[Lisa Chason]

Why We Fight

By Karen Kwiatkowski

02/11/06 "Lew Rockwell" -- -- Director Eugene Jarecki has put together a
wonderful, moving and important film that examines the modern American
military machine and the modern American militaristic mindset. 

His film is the 2004 Sundance Film Festival's Documentary Award-winning
<http://informationclearinghouse.info/article8494.htm> Why We Fight. The
title of the film recalls Frank Capra's World War II films - popular movies
that promoted, eulogized and helped mythologize America's participation and
sacrifice in that war. We fought in World War II for many reasons, but
mostly it seems, because we believed. 

Why We Fight carefully illustrates how our beliefs, our national character,
our shared view of ourselves as Americans have changed since World War II.
Jarecki utilizes President
<http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article5407.htm> Eisenhower's
famous farewell speech of January 17th, 1961. In this speech, Ike warned of
a growing military-industrial complex, and its possible negative impact on
our democracy and our republic. As the late Colonel David Hackworth used to
remind me, Eisenhower spoke of the dangers presented by
military-industrial-congressional complex.

Eisenhower advised there was a ".danger that public policy could itself
become the captive of a scientific-technological elite." He reminded us,
"Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of
the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful
methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together. He
said,

.we - you and I, and our government - must avoid the impulse to live only
for today, plundering for, for our own ease and convenience, the precious
resources of tomorrow. We cannot mortgage the material assets of our
grandchildren without asking the loss also of their political and spiritual
heritage. We want democracy to survive for all generations to come, not to
become the insolvent phantom of tomorrow.

I had read, but never before actually watched Eisenhower's farewell speech
until I saw Why We Fight. Those who are today manning the ship of state in
Washington, D.C., like people my age, completely missed this prophetic
speech. As Ike passed the presidential baton to a fresh new face, a youthful
George W. Bush, like most of his generation, was focused on high school
shenanigans, and the American people basked in long-awaited economic
prosperity.

Ike knew a thing or two about war, American government, and our nascent
military-industrial complex. Eisenhower worried, but we weren't paying
attention - at least in 1961. When asked why he made the film, Jarecki said,
"Americans [today] have a visceral sense that something is rotten, but
no-one can seem to connect the dots.. I wanted to make this film because we
need what Eisenhower called an 'alert and knowledgeable citizenry' to compel
change, to improve the public's ability to monitor those in power."

Why We Fight is filmed in a new kind of America. It is still filled with
everyday people pulling together for glory, Capra-style. But this
documentary carefully and intelligently reveals the present-day fruition of
Ike's darker vision. 

Many everyday Americans are featured in Why We Fight. A father who lost his
son in the Twin Tower attacks on 9-11. Workers making armaments on massive
factory floors, and workers writing global engagement policy prescriptions
from inside carefully appointed urban thinktanks. Politicians and
contractors and military recruiters and soldiers. These simultaneously
<http://www.antiwar.com/justin/?articleid=8484> common and uncommon people
are key to the film's humanity and its directness - because these people are
us. 

However, Jarecki's steady hand reveals that while we are indeed Frank
Capra's Americans, we are today, in Jarecki's words, " .caught in a vortex
of spiraling militarisation and moral and economic bankruptcy, and [we] feel
remote from and powerless to change those forces."

Why We Fight grapples with this sense of moral and economic bankruptcy that
many feel as we stay the course and fight wars in Iraq, and elsewhere. The
film illuminates the "insolvent phantom of tomorrow" that Ike foretold, and
it attempts to get underneath the superficial explanations, and ideological
perspectives. In Jarecki's words, "We tend to hunt for heroes and villains,
rather than study roots of the problem. I wanted to make a film that goes
beyond the focus on the individual."

Jarecki gets it. He understands and clearly articulates how the care and
feeding of the American military leviathan has been, and remains, a shared
role of both Democratic and Republican Parties. There hasn't been an antiwar
party at the national level for decades, and it is easy to see why. What
Cold War competition, massive federalization and sophisticated and
relentless government agitprop pitting "us" against "them" has produced is
summed up in a Raytheon worker's reflection on her job. She pauses for a
moment, and says, "I'd really rather be making toys for Santa." But she
isn't.

Will Washington, D.C. like the film? It is hard to predict whether the Bush
Administration or the loyal opposition in Congress will first launch a stone
at Why We Fight. Jarecki has provided an apolitical history and an
apolitical reality, portraying an America evolved in the dangerous direction
that Eisenhower exactly foretold. 

Can the military-industrial-congressional complex be reined in? Should it
be? To the extent that Jarecki passes judgment on the latter question, he
defers to Eisenhower in the affirmative. It should be "compelled" and
controlled by an alert and knowledgeable citizenry, such that "security and
liberty" may prosper together. But can it be?

The film is perhaps less optimistic of whether it can be reined in, as an
interesting clip with Senator John McCain discussing the growth of the
military industrial complex is cut short by an urgent phone call from the
former CEO of Halliburton, and Vice President of the United States. 

But what I really find inspiring about Why We Fight is that we see the
words, thoughts and deeds of the average American in this movie - the
factory workers, the fathers and mothers and sons and daughters, the
backbone of this nation. To a person, it is these Americans who exude
patriotism and deep abiding love for this country. It is these Americans
who, with all their faults, are founts of common decency and morality.
Jarecki is excruciatingly fair in his portrayal of war-promoting policy
wonks and war policy beneficiaries like Richard Perle, Bill Kristol, Don
Rumsfeld, Dick Cheney and George W. Bush. But the fact remains that these
policy designers simply don't make a hell of a lot of sense. 

Jarecki has both artfully and scientifically pulled away the curtain that
currently shields the pillars of the present-day American
military-industrial-congressional complex. In a time where Abramoff,
Halliburton overcharges, and Duke Cunningham-style "congressional
leadership" has already publicly embarrassed Washington and the Pentagon,
this film will be downplayed by the leadership in Washington, D.C. on both
sides of the aisle. These public servants and the defense corporations in
league with them will say, "Enough already!"

But Why We Fight will eagerly be consumed and digested by millions and
millions of real and loyal Americans who are now weary of strange endless
wars in far away places and an economy wasting under the demands of
voracious spending on "defense." These American, as I did upon watching the
film, will begin to really think about what we have become. These Americans
will become newly awake, newly alert, newly watchful. These Americans will
begin to embrace and assert, as did our forefathers, the blessed idea that
we are governed and directed by our own consent, and none other. Eisenhower
would certainly approve.

Karen Kwiatkowski, Ph.D. [send her mail <mailto:ksusiek at shentel.net> ], a
retired USAF lieutenant colonel, has written on defense issues with a
libertarian perspective for militaryweek.com <http://militaryweek.com/> ,
hosts the call-in radio show American Forum
<http://mp3.rbnlive.com/Karen05.html>  on Saturday nights, and blogs
occasionally for Huffingtonpost.com <http://www.huffingtonpost.com/> . To
receive automatic announcements of new articles and upcoming guests on her
American Forum radio program, click
<mailto:karen_kwiatkowski-subscribe at yahoogroups.com> here.

 
 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.chambana.net/cgi-bin/private/peace-discuss/attachments/20060212/f619706f/attachment.htm