[Peace-discuss] Uncivil Discourse

[John Fettig]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8IeZHZRwC4

Uncivil Discourse

Friday 04 September 2009

by: Bill Moyers

    The editors of THE ECONOMIST magazine say America's health care
debate has become a touch delirious, with people accusing each other
of being evil-mongers, dealers in death, and un-American.

    Well, that's charitable.

    I would say it's more deranged than delirious, and definitely not
un-American.

    Those crackpots on the right praying for Obama to die and be sent
to hell — they're the warp and woof of home-grown nuttiness. So is the
creature from the Second Amendment who showed up at the President's
rally armed to the teeth. He's certainly one of us. Red, white, and
blue kooks are as American as apple pie and conspiracy theories.

    Bill Maher asked me on his show last week if America is still a
great nation. I should have said it's the greatest show on earth.
Forget what you learned in civics about the Founding Fathers — we're
the children of Barnum and Bailey, our founding con men. Their freak
show was the forerunner of today's talk radio.

    Speaking of which: we've posted on our website an essay by the
media scholar Henry Giroux. He describes the growing domination of
hate radio as one of the crucial elements in a "culture of cruelty"
increasingly marked by overt racism, hostility and disdain for others,
coupled with a simmering threat of mob violence toward any political
figure who believes health care reform is the most vital of safety
nets, especially now that the central issue of life and politics is no
longer about working to get ahead, but struggling simply to survive.

    So here we are, wallowing in our dysfunction. Governed — if you
listen to the rabble rousers — by a black nationalist from Kenya
smuggled into the United States to kill Sarah Palin's baby. And yes, I
could almost buy their belief that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass
destruction, only I think he shipped them to Washington, where they've
been recycled as lobbyists and trained in the alchemy of money
laundering, which turns an old-fashioned bribe into a First Amendment
right.

    Only in a fantasy capital like Washington could Sunday morning
talk shows become the high church of conventional wisdom, with
partisan shills treated as holy men whose gospel of prosperity always
seems to boil down to lower taxes for the rich.

    Poor Obama. He came to town preaching the religion of nice. But
every time he bows politely, the harder the Republicans kick him.

    No one's ever conquered Washington politics by constantly saying
"pretty please" to the guys trying to cut your throat.

    Let's get on with it, Mr. President. We're up the proverbial creek
with spaghetti as our paddle. This health care thing could have been
the crossing of the Delaware, the turning point in the next American
Revolution — the moment we put the mercenaries to rout, as General
Washington did the Hessians at Trenton. We could have stamped our
victory "Made in the USA." We could have said to the world, "Look what
we did!" And we could have turned to each other and said, "Thank you."

    As it is, we're about to get health care reform that measures
human beings only in corporate terms of a cost-benefit analysis. I
mean this is topsy-turvy — we should be treating health as a
condition, not a commodity.

    As we speak, Pfizer, the world's largest drug maker, has been
fined a record $2.3 billion dollars as a civil and criminal — yes,
that's criminal, as in fraud — penalty for promoting prescription
drugs with the subtlety of the Russian mafia. It's the fourth time in
a decade Pfizer's been called on the carpet. And these are the people
into whose tender mercies Congress and the White House would deliver
us?

    Come on, Mr. President. Show us America is more than a circus or a
market. Remind us of our greatness as a democracy. When you speak to
Congress next week, just come out and say it. We thought we heard you
say during the campaign last year that you want a government run
insurance plan alongside private insurance — mostly premium-based,
with subsidies for low-and-moderate income people. Open to all
individuals and employees who want to join and with everyone free to
choose the doctors we want. We thought you said Uncle Sam would sign
on as our tough, cost-minded negotiator standing up to the cartel of
drug and insurance companies and Wall Street investors whose only
interest is a company's share price and profits.

    Here's a suggestion, Mr. President: ask Josh Marshall to draft
your speech. Josh is the founder of the website talkingpointsmemo.com.
He's a journalist and historian, not a politician. He doesn't split
things down the middle and call it a victory for the masses. He's
offered the simplest and most accurate description yet of a public
insurance plan — one that essentially asks people: would you like the
option — the voluntary option — of buying into Medicare before you're
65? Check it out, Mr. President.

    This health care thing is make or break for your leadership, but
for us, it's life and death. No more Mr. Nice Guy, Mr. President. We
need a fighter.

    That's it for the Journal. I'm Bill Moyers. See you next time.