[Peace-discuss] Another racist liberal on Haiti

[Karen Medina]

That blog post reminds me of an uncle of mine (with whom I disagree)
who said: "When Colorado had that huge blizzard, they did not wait for
a handout, they started delivering their own mail. Unlike New Orleans
who expected to get rescued. Why didn't they help themselves instead
of complaining?"

On a related note: I hear that Palestinians in Gaza donated items and
money for Haiti. The poorest sharing what little they have. We should
follow their example.

It is hard to hug my neighbor when I need both arms to protect my possessions.

It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a
rich man to enter into the kingdom of God.

-karen medina

On Wed, Feb 10, 2010 at 8:53 PM, C. G. Estabrook <galliher at illinois.edu> wrote:
>        Voodoo, Development and the Culture of Haiti
>        Marty Peretz
>        February 8, 2010
>
> There are many factors which have determined and over-determined the
> miserable history of Haiti, to which almost everybody had become
> accustomed. The recent plague, however, provoked a moment of pity ...
> and also of self-pity, which manifested itself by Haitian anger
> against the aid providers who did not act fast enough or did not bring
> the right equipment or did not bring sufficient aid-workers. Or
> imported clothing when they should have brought water or food. This is
> the understandable petulance of people who usually expect nothing and
> then suddenly become the cause of the moment, the recipients of a
> largesse that will not last.
>
> The very issues of development and underdevelopment are heavily laden
> with ideology. Not just prescriptive of ideologies of left and right.
> But utilitarian models, supposedly neutral. Like a United Nations
> administration of help and reconstruction, as if anything sponsored by
> the U.N. would be anything but corrupt, inefficient, confused, and
> racialist.
>
> I myself proposed what would in effect be a mandate for Haiti overseen
> by the United States. The model could be the American occupation and
> reform of Japan. But, of course, Japan was already a very advanced
> country. So the analogy is at best flawed. To tell the truth, whether
> Japan or not, Haiti would be lucky to be a protectorate (against
> nature and against its own large-scale criminal elements) of America.
> No one in the U.S. is eager for such an encounter. It would be costly.
> It would induce resentment among the hemisphere's "progressives" like
> the buffoon Hugo Chavez, who is leading his oil-rich country into
> poverty and has already led it into despotism and worse. And the
> American left would denounce an American mandate for Haiti as
> imperialism, regardless of the processes or the outcomes. And what
> about the American imperialists, the Republicans? They would think it
> nothing less than insane.
>
> And insane it may seem.
>
> The Haitian narrative is interlaced with the spooky charms of voodoo:
> fright, inference, faith, mystery. These are not traits that are
> conducive to sound plans for economic development or rational
> political discourse. Lawrence Harrison, who once ran USAID in Haiti
> and now is professor at the Fletcher School of Diplomacy at Tufts, has
> written a short but challenging essay on the role of voodoo in Haiti's
> past and the dreadful mortgage it has carried over into Haiti's
> future. It is not a topic politicians and others who are charged with
> the good of Haiti are eager to touch.
>
> But Harrison makes the point that voodoo is not a racialist
> explanation. But it is a cultural explanation. Cultural explanations
> may not explain all. But they always explain much.
>
> <http://www.tnr.com/blog/the-spine/voodoo-development-and-the-culture-haiti>
>
>
> --
> This message has been scanned for viruses and
> dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
> believed to be clean.
>
> _______________________________________________
> Peace-discuss mailing list
> Peace-discuss at lists.chambana.net
> http://lists.chambana.net/mailman/listinfo/peace-discuss
>



-- 
karen medina
<~~~~~~~~~~~~~>
"In this universe, we are given two gifts: the ability to love, and
the ability to ask questions." (Mary Oliver, American poet)
A third gift is the ability to laugh. (Jenifer, a friend)

-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.